George on Stemle

From Stephen George on replacing his fired mentor, Cary Stemle, at LEO...

I went back to catalog/search where I had blogged about Cary's demise, but I don't see anything. It must have been an email to someone that sticks in my head. Anyway, I always enjoyed working with Cary-- trading emails, asking for my expertise, or as an editor of my letters and op-ed pieces. He always seemed professional and competent. He was one of the two most thorough editors with whom I have worked. He always returned emails-- something that is sadly lacking with other papers. In a word, I have no idea why he was canned-- and hope that he lands nicely on his proverbial feet.

Just emerging from college and caked in the stupidly resilient optimism of extreme youth, I fully expected five years ago that any of my numerous queries to magazines and alternative newspapers would yield a job offer. I had been an editor at a college newspaper, which I had turned into an antiwar machine during the run-up to the Iraq invasion — remember when you thought it mattered? — and had managed to impress some of the trade elders affiliated with the thing in the process. Good times.

But we tend to operate in a vacuum in such scenarios, which is partly why so many of us in the country of staggering optimism end up morally and intellectually destitute by age 25. I didn’t get a job. I worked in a deli, then briefly as an assistant to a plaster artisan. So much for those freewheeling days of covering the weirdness du jour.

I continued haranguing everyone I knew even slightly in the business, insisting that given the right shot, I could make a play. Finally, after weeks of my incessant whining, Cary Stemle gave me an assignment. It was small: 100 words on a Sonic Youth show. I had a celebratory drink that night at a bar. I was desperate.

Thus began a working relationship most rare and profound, one that officially ended last Thursday morning without a warning or a word. I didn’t know what was happening when I watched Cary collect a few things and walk out the door. Having spent the last five days rolling this whole thing over and again, I’m still not comfortable with what the hell just went down.

SouthComm Communications, a media and publishing company based in Nashville (see page 3), acquired LEO last Thursday, and the company chose to continue employing all but four of us. How Cary wound up on that short, ugly list I’m not sure, but I’d challenge any assertion that it was based on the job he did.

Cary came to LEO 10 years ago, though the last five were his most essential. When founder John Yarmuth sold the paper to the Times Publishing Co. of Pennsylvania in 2003, Cary bit his lip, absorbed an onslaught of misdirected criticism from the loyalists — LEO had sold out, was dead, useless, so forth — and set to work ensuring that the paper’s voice would not be compromised. He endured what purists would consider numerous offenses, including a push to include more “people” photos in the newspaper, to print the whole thing in color, and so on — things to make LEO more “appealing” to readers and potential advertisers. While certainly not dismissible, these are the things that make the hardcore cringe, and Cary is hardcore. Simply, he is the reason LEO has continued its run of excellence and its annual parade of journalism awards, and adapted to its new world with gusto, all despite obvious falling profits and the shrinkage concomitant to that.

As an editor, Cary felt a deep responsibility to this city and its constituents to do his very best to discover both corruption and hope, the two sides of the ever-flipping coin that is the only reality in which we can invest. He navigated trenches with confidence and panache, listened with a golden ear and let you be who you were, which turned out to be pretty important for me.

Cary has been a supreme mentor. While my name has appeared in LEO something like 300 times since I came on staff here in January 2005, he deserves the laudations that have come with it (and the sharp criticism, hate mail and other things I’ll continue forwarding him). I can be terribly stubborn, and for a time believed I needed no such guidance. So Cary came with it inconspicuously, like placing a few rocks near the mouth of a stream to redirect some water but not interrupt the general flow. His genius as a writer, editor and thinker is subtle and conversational, and his vocabulary is something to behold — as you all know. His lessons were straight: be thorough and sincere, listen before you talk and think before you write, and keep your goddamn head up, because it’s really not so bad.

Journalism is “a low trade and a habit worse than heroin,” Hunter S. Thompson once wrote. I don’t imagine Cary will kick it anytime soon. Neither will we.